School Reports and My Past

School Reports and My Past

I often look through my old school reports. It’s been difficult the last couple of years because they all talk about Ben and refer to that boy, someone who, although it used to be me I no longer recognize.

I recognize the words and know they refer to me, but whenever I read that name or those male pronouns I feel a cognitive dissonance. It was me, but at the same time (and strongly) it is not me. Not the person I am now.

And yet… I still open that old folder and read those words.

IMAG0283

IMAG0280IMAG0281The subjects (from top to bottom) were Chemistry, Design, English, French and Geography.

I can’t emphasize enough how hard it is to read “he” and “his”, or to see “B” or “Ben”. Imagine reading something about you that refers to you as someone else. Not only that, but someone of a different gender!

I know these reports are mine, I know they are referring to me, but I’m a woman called Alexandra; these reports about some boy called Benjamin feel emotionally like they’re about someone else although I know rationally that they refer to me.

I’ve had conflicted thoughts about my daughter. I know she has a mother and a father, but I am not comfortable describing  myself as her father. I’m one of her two parents, sure, but I can’t bring myself to think of myself in such male terms as a father.

She calls me Alex, not “Dad”, which I’m happy about: I feel very uncomfortable with the male implications of father but I also recognize that I am not her mother. There’s a word missing from English, one to describe a female parent who did not give birth to the child.

To say it hurts is such an understatement. It tears my heart to pieces, leaves me crushed and beaten. I tell people she’s my daughter but I feel inhibited from saying that I’m her “parent” because I can’t say I’m her mother and I don’t believe “father” is appropriate.

Technically speaking I am her father, but emotionally I can’t accept that label. I can’t accept anything that suggests a male identity I don’t identify with. It’s frustrating, but I can’t find an answer to my conundrum.

4 thoughts on “School Reports and My Past

  1. So difficult Alex – I immediately thought the new word should be “other” – as in mother without the m and making allusion to alternative. Hmm…no. Opting for “parent” and following the no explanations rule is perhaps better. It’s like some of the other highly personal questions you’ve blogged about “not going there”, maybe? I just know there is a word waiting to be invented. xxxx

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m starting to come round to the word mother. Being adopted myself I could reasonably claim two mothers (although I don’t even know the name of my birth mother–I was never inclined to seek any information), so of all people I ought to recognise that one can be a mother without having given birth to the child. Perhaps it is best to ignore the mechanics that led to the present and simply accept that as a female parent there is one word that fits, as it fit the woman who adopted and raised me. xxxx

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Great answer – I wanted to suggest this too, but felt it wasn’t my place. I think mother is used flexibly anyway in many cases. We adopt mothers and become adopted by others in this role. xxx

        Liked by 1 person

I'd love to hear your thoughts on this.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s